Should Ashkenazi Jews Put “Middle Eastern” on the Common App? A Guide to Navigating the Labyrinth of Identity on College Applications
So, you’re an Ashkenazi Jew, and you’re staring at that dreaded “ethnicity” section on the Common App. You’re probably thinking, “Do I put ‘Middle Eastern’? Is that even accurate? What will the admissions committee think?” You’re not alone. This is a question that’s been plaguing Ashkenazi Jews for generations, and it’s a bit of a minefield.
Let’s break down the complexities:
Fact #1: Ashkenazi Jews are indeed of Middle Eastern descent.
This is a no-brainer, folks. The ancestors of Ashkenazi Jews originally hailed from the Middle East. It’s like saying Italians are from Italy – it’s a matter of historical fact.
Fact #2: But Ashkenazi Jews have a long and complex history in Europe.
Think of them like the ultimate cultural melting pot. They lived in Europe for centuries, blending with the local populations and developing a unique cultural identity. This doesn’t negate their Middle Eastern origins; it simply adds another layer to their story.
Fact #3: The Common App doesn’t always offer a “Middle Eastern” option.
This is where things get tricky. And to be honest, the whole “race” and “ethnicity” categorization on college applications feels like a relic from a bygone era. It’s a system that often fails to capture the nuanced realities of human identity, especially for groups like Ashkenazi Jews.
So, what should you do?
Here’s the brutally honest truth: There’s no “right” answer. It depends on your personal comfort level and how you identify.
Option 1: “White”
Many Ashkenazi Jews choose to put “white” because that’s the category that most closely aligns with their lived experience in Western society. After all, they’ve been assimilated into “white” culture for generations.
Option 2: “Other”
This is a safe bet, especially if you’re unsure about the “Middle Eastern” designation. It allows you to acknowledge that you don’t fit neatly into any pre-defined box.
Option 3: “Two or More Races”
If you feel comfortable acknowledging both your Middle Eastern and European heritage, this is a viable option. It reflects the complex tapestry of your identity.
Option 4: “Middle Eastern” (if available)
If the Common App offers a “Middle Eastern” option, and you feel comfortable identifying with that label, go for it. It’s a way to own your heritage and challenge the narrow categories that often limit our understanding of identity.
But here’s the real kicker: The Common App is just a piece of paper. Don’t let it define you. Your identity is about so much more than a checkmark on a form. It’s about your experiences, your values, your culture, and your sense of self.
A Word on the “Jewish” Box
While the “Jewish” checkbox on the Common App may seem like a straightforward choice, it can also be a source of discomfort for some. It’s important to remember that “Jewish” is not just a religion; it’s also a cultural and ethnic identity.
For some, checking the “Jewish” box feels like a way to acknowledge their heritage, while others may feel it’s too limiting. Ultimately, the decision is a personal one.
Let’s Talk About the Elephant in the Room: Anti-Semitism
The truth is, there’s a lingering fear that choosing “Middle Eastern” could lead to negative stereotypes and discrimination. This fear isn’t unfounded. Anti-Semitism is a real and persistent problem, and it’s important to be aware of it.
However, it’s crucial to remember that embracing your heritage doesn’t mean accepting discrimination. It’s about reclaiming your identity and challenging the prejudices that seek to define you.
The Power of Open Dialogue
Ultimately, the best approach is to be honest with yourself and your own identity. If you’re uncertain, don’t be afraid to talk to your parents, grandparents, or other family members to learn more about your family history and heritage.
And if you’re still feeling lost, talk to a trusted friend, a counselor, or even a college admissions advisor. They can help you navigate these complex issues and make the decision that feels right for you.
The Common App is just a tiny piece of the college application process. Your identity is about so much more than a checkmark on a form. Don’t let the anxieties of college applications overshadow the beauty and complexity of who you are.
Need further help or resources about Ashkenazi Jewish identity and ethnicity? Reach out to our community at JobLoving for personalized advice, support, and a safe space to explore your own journey of self-discovery.