Is My Common App Essay Pretentious? A Confession From a College Admissions Expert
Okay, let’s be real. You’re staring at your Common App essay, feeling like you’re about to write the most pretentious thing since that time your neighbor tried to make gourmet hot dogs out of kangaroo meat. You’re thinking, “Is this essay going to make me sound like I’m trying too hard?”
The answer? Maybe. But don’t panic just yet. We all have that nagging fear of sounding like we just stepped out of a Wes Anderson film, especially when the stakes are as high as getting into college.
So, how do you know if your essay is veering into the territory of “pretentious”? Let’s break it down.
The Telltale Signs of a Pretentious Common App Essay
- The “I’m So Unique” Syndrome: You’re bragging about how different you are, but it sounds more like a list of things you think are cool than a genuine reflection of your personality. Think “I’m a world traveler who’s climbed Mount Everest and speaks fluent Mandarin” versus “I’m a curious person who loves exploring new cultures.”
- The “I’m Better Than You” Vibe: Your essay is dripping with self-importance. You might be comparing yourself favorably to others or subtly hinting at your superiority. Newsflash: Colleges want students who are humble and collaborative, not arrogant know-it-alls.
- The “I’m Too Cool For School” Attitude: You’re trying to be edgy and ironic, but it just comes off as forced and insincere. Remember, your essay should be about your passions and experiences, not a desperate attempt to impress the admissions committee with your “uniqueness.”
- The “I’m a Literary Genius” Posture: You’re using overly complex language, trying to sound profound, and throwing in obscure literary references that your grandmother wouldn’t understand. Keep it simple, folks. Clarity is king.
What to Do Instead: Be Authentically You
Let’s be honest, most of us aren’t world-renowned philosophers or Nobel Prize winners. You’re just a regular teen trying to get into college. Embrace that.
Here are some tips for writing an essay that’s authentic, engaging, and (most importantly) not pretentious:
- Focus on your story: Tell a story that’s genuinely important to you. Maybe it’s about overcoming a challenge, discovering a passion, or realizing your values.
- Keep it real: Don’t try to be someone you’re not. Be honest about your experiences and your personality.
- Show, don’t tell: Instead of saying “I’m a hard worker,” tell a story about a time you worked hard and what you learned from that experience.
- Write in your own voice: Don’t try to sound like a professional writer or copy someone else’s style. Let your personality shine through.
- Get feedback: Ask a trusted teacher, mentor, or family member to read your essay and give you honest feedback.
The Bottom Line: Authenticity Trumps Pretentiousness
Think of your Common App essay as a chance to introduce yourself to the colleges. You wouldn’t show up to a job interview in a tuxedo and start quoting Nietzsche, right? Keep it real, keep it relatable, and be yourself. That’s the most important ingredient for a successful essay.
Remember: The goal of your Common App essay isn’t to sound smart; it’s to show who you are and what you can bring to the college community.
Got More Questions? Connect with the JobLoving Community!
Is your head still spinning? Need more advice on crafting the perfect Common App essay? Don’t stress! The JobLoving community is here to help. Join the conversation and connect with other students, mentors, and experts who can offer guidance and support. You’re not alone in this journey!
Let’s get you into the college of your dreams – without sounding like a pretentious robot.